Ivan Shishkin, Rye (1878)

Discussions

A bad deal in French Tarot

0 messages

Solution

Solution by Ancient Tree · EN

Let nn be the initial number of players, and kk the number of cards each player has, except for the last one, who has only k2k-2.
We therefore have:
78=(n1)k+k2=nk278=(n-1)k+k-2=nk-2And hence nk=80nk=80.
Note that the cards were dealt four at a time, so the number of cards each player has (except for the last one...) is a multiple of 4:
k=4tk=4t(where, incidentally, tt is the number of rounds of dealing).
We therefore obtain
4nt=80,hencent=20.4nt=80,\quad\text{hence}\quad nt=20.

This leaves only the following possibilities:

  • n=20n=20, t=1t=1
  • n=1n=1, t=20t=20 (excluded, since there are several players)
  • n=10n=10, t=2t=2
  • n=2n=2, t=10t=10 (excluded, since the statement specifies that after the player leaves, several players remain).
  • n=5n=5, t=4t=4
  • n=4n=4, t=5t=5.

There is one condition left to consider: since the remaining n1n-1 players divide all the cards of the player who left equally among themselves, this implies that
n1  divides  k2=4t2n-1\;\text{divides}\;k-2=4t-2

But checking the 4 remaining possibilities, only one of them is compatible with this condition.
Indeed:

  • n=20n=20, t=1t=1 is impossible, since 201=1920-1=19 does not divide 4×12=24\times 1-2=2.
  • n=10n=10, t=2t=2 is impossible, since 101=910-1=9 does not divide 4×22=64\times 2-2=6.
  • n=5n=5, t=4t=4 is impossible, since 51=45-1=4 does not divide 4×42=144\times 4-2=14.
  • n=4n=4, t=5t=5 is possible, since 41=34-1=3 does indeed divide 4×52=184\times 5-2=18.

Therefore, there could only have been n=4n=4 players initially; and hence only 3 players remain.

No messages yet.