Ivan Shishkin, Rye (1878)

Discussions

Finite groups with 3 conjugacy classes

0 messages

Solution

Solution by Sequoia · EN

Let GG act on X:=GX:=G by conjugation, that is via the action (g,x)G×Xgx=gxg1G(g,x)\in G\times X\longmapsto g\cdot x=gxg^{-1}\in G.

Thus the orbit of xx under this action is Ox:={gxg1,gG}O_x:=\{gxg^{-1}, g\in G\}, i.e., the conjugacy class of xx, and its stabilizer is Stab(x):={gG/gxg1=x}Stab(x):=\{g\in G/ gxg^{-1}=x\}, i.e., the set of elements that commute with xx.

We know that the set of orbits forms a partition of XX, that is, there exist x1,,xrXx_1,\dots,x_r\in X such that X=i=1rOxiX=\bigsqcup_{i=1}^r O_{x_i}. But there are only three conjugacy classes here, so r=3r=3. Also, one of these classes contains the identity element ee, whose orbit is reduced to itself since it commutes with everyone. We thus have the equality X={e}OxOyX=\{e\}\sqcup O_x\sqcup O_y for some x,yXx,y\in X.

Let us now consider cardinalities: we find #G=1+#Ox+#Oy\#G=1+\#O_x+\#O_y. But the cardinalities #Ox\#O_x and #Oy\#O_y can also be written as #G#Stab(x)\frac{\#G}{\#Stab(x)} (samely for yy), so we finally obtain
#G=1+#G(1#Stab(x)+1#Stab(y)).\#G=1+\#G\left(\frac{1}{\#Stab(x)}+\frac{1}{\#Stab(y)}\right).

Which can be rewritten as
#Stab(x)#Stab(y)(#G1)=#G(#Stab(x)+#Stab(y))\#Stab(x)\cdot\#Stab(y)\cdot(\#G-1)=\#G\cdot(\#Stab(x)+\#Stab(y))But since #G\#G and #G1\#G-1 have gcd 11, then #G1\#G-1 divides #Stab(x)+#Stab(y)\#Stab(x)+\#Stab(y). However Stab(x)Stab(x) and Stab(y)Stab(y) are subgroups of GG. Say that one of them equal GG, then #G1\#G-1 divides the cardinality of the other one minus one, and so it also has to equal GG. But Stab(x)=GStab(x)=G iff xx commutes with any element of GG and samely for yy. Hence G=Z/3ZG=\Z/3\Z.

Now assume that both Stab(x)Stab(x) and Stab(x)Stab(x) do not equal GG. Then, by Lagrange formula, their cardinal has to be less than or equal to #G2\frac{\#G}{2}, so their sum has to be less than #G\#G and is a multiple of #G1\#G-1. Hence it has to equal #G1\#G-1.
Finally one gets the two equations:
#G1=#Stab(x)+#Stab(y)and#G=#Stab(x)#Stab(y).\#G-1=\#Stab(x)+\#Stab(y)\,\,\text{and}\,\,\#G=\#Stab(x)\cdot\#Stab(y).

Since we know that eStab(x)Stab(y)e\in Stab(x)\cap Stab(y), let us write a:=#Stab(x)1a:=\#Stab(x)-1 and b:=#Stab(y)1b:=\#Stab(y)-1, which gives a+b=#G3a+b=\#G-3 and 2=ab2=ab. Hence, without loss of generality, one deduces that a=2a=2 and b=1b=1 hence #Stab(x)=3,#Stab(y)=2\#Stab(x)=3,\#Stab(y)=2 and #G=6\#G=6.

Finally, there exists only one non-abelian group of order 66 (it has to be non-abelian to have only 33 conjugacy classes), which is S3S_3. This concludes the proof.

No messages yet.