Ivan Shishkin, Rye (1878)

Discussions

The wooden cube

0 messages

Solution

Solution by Sequoia · EN

The surface of a square appearing on the cube is x2x^2 and the volume of the cube is x3x^3. They are all integers by assumption. We will show that xx is indeed an integer.

Since x=x3x2\displaystyle x=\frac{x^3}{x^2}, it must be rational. Let pp be a prime number and vp(y)v_p(y) the pp-adic valuation of a rational number yy. Then one gets that vp(x)v_p(x) is well-defined and that vp(x2)=2vp(x)v_p(x^2)=2v_p(x) is an even positive integer because x2x^2 is a positive integer. Hence, for all prime pp, vp(x)v_p(x) is a positive integer. Hence xx is an integer.

No messages yet.